⚖️ The ship's victory in the matter of mobility!
Our client waived the fine from the territorial recruitment center and social support for any disruption to the mobility sector. Ale law na yogo botsi!
💪 Summary of the professional position of lawyer Alik Zamirovich Kerimov, Another Administrative Court of Appeal in reference No. 641/1247/25, having passed the ruling on the fine.
📌 The court clearly stated: since personal data is already available through electronic interaction between state registries, there is no basis for corroboration (part 3 of article 210-1 of the Code of Administrative Offenses, part 3 of article 14 of the Law No. 1951-VIII).
📌 Part 3 of Article 14 of the Law of Ukraine No. 1951-VIII “On the Unified State Register of Conscripts, Military Conscripts and Reservists”: personal data is collected by the register authorities through electronic interaction with others state registers. Sent confirmation to those who have not specified their personal data in each of the ways prescribed by law in the terms from May 19 to April 16, 2024, the panel of judges is respectful of the undetermined, the fragments The primary reason for this situation is to establish administrative authority over the individual and the very impossibility of removing the individual’s personal data through electronic communication with others information and communication systems, registers (including public ones), databases (banks) of data, as well as daily evidence that during the hour of passage of the positive VLK 01.09.2022 with the knowledge of its bordered affiliation before military service at the military hour according to On July 16, 2024, the personal data of the positive worker was changed, which obviously required clarification.
Based on the above, the panel of judges came to the conclusion about the number of cases to take into account, so that in the actions of the positive person there is a clear warehouse of administrative violations, transferred to the third part of Statute 210-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and the very violation of legislation about defense, mobilization preparation and mobilization.
✅ The client has passed the medical examination, whose data is entered before the register - which means the fine is non-exempt (Article 1, Article 22 of the Law of Ukraine “On mobility training and mobilization”, Part 10 Art. 1 of Law No. 3633-IX).
📌 Summary: The state authorities are responsible for their actions in accordance with the law, and the citizens do not bear responsibility for the fact that the state already takes their tribute - the practice of courts confirms this principle.
📄 The full text of the statement is available here: https://opendatabot.ua/court/127664511-5573747bdbeeed8f3feec64da3bf0c5f
✅ AB "Kerimov and Partners" - real defense, real victories, real results!